Skip to main content
HomeCriminal Justice

Education or Incarceration

Nora Rupert, Carlton T. Mayers and Narnike Pierre-Grant join LWV Broward members Ruby Green and Jennifer Perelman to discuss how the educational system can prevent student school disruptions that may lead to incarceration. August 25, 2021

Incarcerated with Indignity: The Mistreatment of Women Behind Bars

Attorney Teresa Williams, who represented Tammmy Jackson, and Tray Johns, activist for incarcerated women, discussed a broad range of topics affecting women in jail, including the need for proper medical care (physical and mental). Hosted by the League of Women Voters

Criminal Justice

 

The role of the criminal justice system is to prevent crime and promote public safety. Current research indicates successful systems focus on rehabilitation and support to prevent recidivism. However, some communities experience excessive force and surveillance by the police; other individuals waste away in prisons serving sentences far out of proportion to their offenses. 


The situation is even more dire regarding juvenile offenders. The mistreatment of juveniles within our criminal justice system is commonplace. The state of Florida prosecutes more children AS ADULTS than any other state in the nation. As a result, there are cases of children being incarcerated in adult facilities. We believe that the primary purpose of juvenile detention is REHABILITATION, not retribution. 


Contact: Narnike Pierre-Grant (narnike@hotmail.com).


We support:

  • a criminal justice system that is just, effective, equitable, transparent, and that fosters public trust at all stages, including policing practices, pre-trial procedures, sentencing, incarceration, and re-entry;
  • the elimination of systemic bias, including the disproportionate policing and incarceration of marginalized communities;
  • policing practices that promote safety for both law enforcement officers and the communities they serve;
  • collaboration between government and community throughout every stage of the criminal justice system;
  • a focus on humane treatment and rehabilitation with the goal of promoting the successful reentry into communities of those who have been incarcerated; and
  • reliance on evidence-based research in decision-making about law-enforcement programs and policies (including scheduled, periodic audits of program and policy effectiveness).

 

Local experts discuss gun violence and our children in a recent League program


A stellar panel, moderators and involved audience conversed on "The Impact of Children and Gun Violence” on March 29 at a meeting organized by LWV of Broward, Young Professionals Network of the Broward County Urban League, T.J. Reddick Bar Association and Race and the Races.

Dr. Michael Brannon, a forensic psychologist and director of the Institute for Behavioral Science and the Law, answered the first questions concerning the impact of gun violence on the brains of developing children. Brannon acknowledged that it was difficult to help kids feel safe and trust in the current climate. They undergo drills at school, hear about shootings on tv, and know the child who is missing from the next desk. They also pick up their parents’ anxieties.
Brannon says the less exposure children have to news, social media and video games in which violence is normalized, the less likely they are to develop symptoms such as overwhelming anxiety, which can affect brain development.

As to the children who perpetuate violence, Broward state attorney Harold F. Pryor believes they need to be identified and helped long before their cases reach his desk. In kindergarten some children are bullies, hurt others and show a lack of empathy. They need family focused programs with community based connections.


We also need to hold people in the video game industry accountable for putting profit over our children’s welfare. The criminal justice system is not designed to protect children. Once they’ve committed murder Pryor needs to decide whether to try them as minors, and get them some services until they reach adulthood, or try them as adults and incarcerate them for longer to protect the community. He admits this is always a hard decision.

Defense Attorney Kaysia Earley, Esq contributed to a lively conversation about parental responsibility and community based programs. She noted that parents are responsible if they have a gun in the house. They are negligent if the child has access. She noted that for therapists, young men will probably not talk to anyone in a suit who doesn’t look like them. A community activist at the meeting suggested hiring men who are out of long terms in prison, who can’t get jobs because of that, to talk to youngsters about the choices they make in life. Earley urged those present not to give hope or the fight to protect our children.

The program was moderated by Ruby Green, who works for the state's attorney office and co-chairs LWV Broward criminal justice committee, Sandra Cherfrere, co-host of Race and the Races and Valerie Waldon, program chair of the Young Professionals Network of the Broward County Urban League

Thanks to League volunteer Ronni Sandroff for this report.